Mining operations depend on electric motors to keep essential infrastructure running. Among the most critical applications are dewatering pumps, which help control groundwater, and ventilation blowers, essential for maintaining safe underground working conditions.
Star-delta starters have long been used to reduce motor starting current. However, in some mining applications, star-delta starters may not provide the starting torque required by the load, and the transition from star to delta can cause electrical and mechanical disturbances. A correctly selected soft starter offers a different approach: it controls motor voltage during acceleration and, where the application and settings permit, helps manage starting current and mechanical stress. The right choice depends on the motor, driven load and available power supply.
Dewatering pumps remove groundwater entering shafts, declines and working areas. If pumping capacity is reduced, water can restrict access, affect equipment and disrupt operations. Ventilation blowers circulate air and help remove heat, dust, fumes and potentially hazardous gases. A ventilation interruption can therefore become a safety-critical event, depending on the mine's ventilation design, standby capacity and operating procedures.
These systems often operate in demanding conditions and may be supplied by long distribution networks, limited-capacity utility connections or onsite generation. Starting performance must be considered as part of the whole installation, not simply as a motor-control setting.
A star-delta starter initially connects the motor windings in star and then changes to delta for normal running. This reduces the voltage applied to each winding during the initial stage and typically reduces starting current. However, the reduced voltage also limits the torque available during acceleration. For a star-delta starter, starting torque in the star connection is commonly around one-third of the motor's direct-on-line starting torque under comparable conditions.
That torque may be insufficient for some loaded pumps or high-inertia blowers. The motor can take longer to accelerate, draw elevated current for longer than expected, or fail to reach the required speed. The changeover from star to delta can also produce a transient current or torque disturbance. Its severity depends on motor characteristics, load, speed at transition and switching conditions.
These limitations do not mean star-delta starting is unsuitable for every mining motor. It can remain a cost-effective choice where the load can accelerate with the available torque and the transition is acceptable. Replacement should be based on observed performance and engineering assessment, rather than on the starting method alone.
Pump starting requirements vary with pump design, static head, valve position, pipeline conditions and whether the pump starts against a loaded system. If available motor torque is too low, acceleration can be prolonged or unsuccessful. During stopping, an abrupt change in flow can contribute to hydraulic transients, including water hammer. A soft starter with an appropriate soft-stop function may help reduce these effects in suitable installations, but pump-system design and operating conditions remain important.
Large fans and blowers can have substantial rotational inertia. They may require a carefully managed acceleration profile and enough torque to reach operating speed within the motor's thermal limits. Engineers should assess acceleration time, permitted starts per hour, motor heating, driven-load torque and any damper or airflow constraints before selecting settings or equipment.
A soft starter does not create torque independently of the motor. With a conventional voltage-controlled soft starter, reducing applied voltage also reduces available torque. Current limits must therefore be selected with the load's torque requirements and the required acceleration time in mind.
Motor starting affects the supply system as well as the motor. A large starting current can cause a voltage dip, particularly where the network is electrically weak or the source has limited capacity. The resulting disturbance may affect other connected equipment, including drives, control systems and protection devices. In mines supplied by generators, large motor starts also need to be assessed against generator capability and voltage-regulation performance.
A soft starter can help manage the current drawn during acceleration and avoid the discrete star-to-delta changeover. The actual improvement depends on the motor, load, current-limit setting, source impedance, generator response and other network characteristics. It should be verified through calculations or measurements where network stability is a concern; a soft starter alone cannot guarantee that voltage dips or trips will be eliminated.
Abrupt torque changes during starting can place additional stress on couplings, shafts, bearings, gearboxes, pump components and fan drive systems. Repeated stress may contribute to wear and maintenance requirements, although actual effects depend on the equipment and duty cycle.
By controlling voltage during acceleration, a soft starter can provide a smoother start than a conventional star-delta transition when correctly sized and configured. Some soft starters also provide controlled deceleration, which can be useful for pump applications. Engineers should confirm the available functions for the selected model and application rather than assume that every starter provides the same control options.
The appropriate solution depends on the motor's rated voltage and power, load characteristics, network capacity, installation conditions and required protection. Low-voltage soft starters are used across many auxiliary and process applications. Medium-voltage soft starters may be appropriate for larger motors such as major dewatering pumps, ventilation blowers and other high-power mine equipment. Motor size alone does not determine the choice; the actual electrical design and site requirements must be reviewed.
When evaluating a replacement, engineers should consider:
A replacement assessment is worth considering when one or more of the following issues are recurring:
Before selecting a replacement, collect the motor nameplate data, load details, existing starter settings, starting-current measurements if available, acceleration time, trip history and relevant network information. This information helps determine whether a soft starter is suitable and how it should be specified.
|
Consideration |
Star-delta starter |
Soft starter |
|
Starting torque |
Reduced during star starting |
Adjustable starting profile, subject to available torque |
|
Transition |
Changes from Start to Delta |
No star-to-delta changeover stage |
|
Current management |
Depends on motor and transition behaviour |
Current limit can be configured |
|
Application fit |
Depends on load and starting requirements |
Depends on load, motor and network requirements |
Neither method is automatically the right choice for every motor. The comparison should be made against the application's starting requirements, supply limitations, protection needs and lifecycle considerations.
For critical mining equipment, motor starting is part of the wider reliability and electrical-system design. Star-delta starters remain suitable for some duties, but their reduced torque during the star stage and the changeover to delta can be limiting for demanding loads or constrained networks.
A correctly selected and configured soft starter can provide controlled acceleration, help manage starting current and reduce abrupt mechanical transitions. The best outcome comes from matching the starting method to the motor, load and supply, then verifying that the settings meet the site's operating requirements.
Solcon-IGEL provides low- and medium-voltage soft-starting solutions for industrial motor applications. For mining installations, the starting requirements, motor data and network conditions should be reviewed to identify the most appropriate solution.